A Dutch court has rejected a copyright infringement claim brought by handbag label Wandler against luxury fashion house Loewe, finding that while Wandler’s Ida bag qualifies for copyright protection, Loewe’s Whisker design does not infringe those protected rights.
The November 11 ruling from the Amsterdam District Court offers a timely illustration of the distinction between a fashion design qualifying for copyright protection and a competing product actually infringing that protection, with implications for fashion brands navigating the boundaries of creative freedom and intellectual property rights.
Wandler’s Ida bag qualifies for copyright protection
The dispute centered on Wandler’s Ida handbag and Loewe’s Whisker bag. Wandler’s Ida formed part of its Fall 2025 collection, with the design shown to buyers in January and February 2025 and subsequently presented in Paris in May. The first Ida bag was sold on July 4, 2025. Loewe unveiled the Whisker during Paris Fashion Week in March 2026, before launching the bag globally in August.
Wandler argued that Loewe’s design infringed its copyright in the Ida, seeking an injunction to prevent the Whisker from being sold in the Netherlands. Wandler relied on a combination of 10 design features that it said reflected the creative choices of its designer.
The Amsterdam court agreed that the combination of the 10 elements was sufficiently original to qualify for copyright protection. It found that the combination reflected the designer’s free and creative choices and personality, rather than being dictated by technical considerations or consisting of merely banal features.
The court did not, however, determine whether the individual elements were independently protected. Its finding related to the combination of the design features.
Similarity did not establish infringement
Despite recognizing copyright in the Ida, the court refused to prohibit Loewe’s Whisker bag from being sold. In assessing infringement, the court considered whether the protected creative elements of the Ida had been recognizably reproduced in the Whisker without authorization. This approach reflects EU copyright principles, including the Court of Justice of the European Union’s December 2025 ruling in joined cases C-580/23 and C-795/23, Mio and Konektra.
The court identified similarities between the bags but also found differences in how the shared design elements had been executed. In particular, it pointed to the Whisker’s straight rear construction and more pronounced asymmetrical shape, which gives the bag a forward-tilting appearance.
The court concluded that Loewe had given the shared design elements its own creative expression, resulting in a bag with its own original character. Accordingly, the infringement claim was unsuccessful. The court also considered whether Loewe had been aware of Wandler’s Ida design. It regarded it as unlikely that Loewe was entirely unfamiliar with Wandler’s work, given the labels’ presence in the fashion market, media coverage and shared retail channels.
However, the court did not consider it necessary to determine whether Loewe had drawn inspiration from the Ida or created the Whisker independently. Its conclusion was that the Whisker did not recognizably reproduce the protected creative expression of the Ida.
Loewe’s counterclaim also fails
The dispute extended beyond Wandler’s allegation. Loewe brought a counterclaim against Wandler, arguing that the Ida infringed its copyright in the design of an overhanging zipper strip featured in earlier Loewe bag designs, including the Madrid and Strip Shoulder Bag.
The court rejected Loewe’s counterclaim, finding that Wandler had made its own creative choices in developing the zipper strip, including its overhang, curved shape, and rounded ends. The resulting design was considered an original work in its own right, despite potentially drawing inspiration from Loewe’s earlier designs. The court therefore refused the requested injunctions on both sides. Wandler was ordered to pay Loewe’s legal costs of €2,101 in the main proceedings, while costs in relation to Loewe’s counterclaim were assessed at zero.
Where fashion copyright protection stops
The ruling highlights an important distinction for fashion businesses: copyright protection for an original product design does not necessarily prevent competitors from incorporating similar elements into their own designs. Under EU copyright principles, applied art is not subject to a higher originality threshold than other categories of work. Originality rests on the expression of the author’s free and creative choices, rather than on a more demanding test specifically designed for products such as handbags, furniture or other commercial goods.
However, protection is directed at the original creative expression itself. The existence of copyright in a combination of design features does not automatically prevent another designer from using comparable shapes, construction elements, or aesthetic ideas where the protected creative expression has not been recognizably reproduced.
The decision reinforces the importance of documenting the creative development of product designs, identifying the elements that contribute to originality, and understanding the scope of the rights being asserted. It also demonstrates that a copying allegation may be difficult to establish even where similarities are evident and the claimant’s design is itself protected.
The ruling is a reminder that copyright can offer meaningful protection to fashion designs, but it is not a monopoly over a particular aesthetic or style. The boundary between inspiration and infringement remains a question of the creative expression reproduced in the competing product.

Written by Elizabeth Jordan
Senior Industry Engagement Manager, CTC Legal Media
You may also like…
BIP Asia Forum and Entrepreneur Day open today
Advancing innovation and global expansion November 19, 2026 – The 16th Business of IP Asia Forum (BIP Asia Forum),...
GTA VI: the trademark strategy behind gaming’s biggest launch
As Grand Theft Auto VI hits the market, its launch highlights the growing commercial value of video game intellectual...
Adobe temporarily blocked from using Firefly Foundry branding
Adobe has been granted a preliminary injunction preventing it from using the Foundry name in its generative artificial...
Contact us to write for out Newsletter












