Rotating Image Link
Clarivate Trademark Filing Trends 2026
Published November 16, 2026

Former competition chief Rod Sims has criticized proposals that would require copyright owners to take technical steps to prevent artificial intelligence companies from using their work for training, warning that the approach could undermine creators’ existing rights.

Australia’s proposed changes to copyright rules governing artificial intelligence (AI) have come under renewed criticism, with former Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) chair Rod Sims warning that an opt-out system could leave creators and publishers struggling to protect their work.

Speaking to The Australian on November 16, Sims described the proposed approach as deeply flawed, arguing that copyright owners should not have to take additional technical measures to retain rights they already possess.

The proposals being considered by the Australian government would allow AI developers to train their models on certain online copyrighted material unless the relevant rights holders actively opt out. Under the proposed arrangements, creators could be expected to use digital protections, including machine-readable signals such as robots.txt files, to communicate that their material should be excluded from AI training.

Sims questioned whether such an approach would provide meaningful protection in practice. A robots.txt file can instruct automated web crawlers not to access particular website content, but it is a voluntary technical standard that relies on crawlers respecting the instructions. It does not, by itself, prevent access by developers that choose to disregard it.

He argued that making copyright protection dependent on technical compliance would place an unreasonable burden on creators and publishers, particularly smaller organizations and individuals without the resources to continually monitor and maintain their online protections. Sims also questioned the underlying principle of requiring rights holders to opt out of a system in which their material would otherwise be available for AI training.

Concerns over control and compensation

The criticism comes amid wider debate over how Australia should balance the development of its AI industry with the rights of authors, publishers, artists and other copyright owners. Government consultation proposals have explored arrangements under which AI companies could obtain legal authorization to train on online copyrighted material without securing individual permission from every rights holder. Options have included payments through a central body or agreements with representative rights-holder organizations, alongside an opt-out mechanism.

Sims has also criticized the prospect of replacing individual control with collective payment arrangements. He warned that creators could lose influence over how their work is used and receive inadequate compensation, while AI companies benefit from access to material that might otherwise require licensing.

The Digital Creators Coalition, which represents publishers and the US recording industry, has also raised concerns about the proposals. Its objections include the potential impact on creator revenues, voluntary licensing arrangements and employment across the creative industries.

However, the government has not finalized any changes to copyright law. Attorney-General Michelle Rowland previously ruled out introducing a broad text and data mining exception that would allow AI developers to use Australian creative works without permission or payment.

International implications for AI copyright

The Australian debate has implications beyond the country’s borders, as governments worldwide consider whether copyright owners should have to actively reserve their rights against AI training or whether developers should obtain permission before using protected material.

An opt-out approach would shift much of the practical responsibility for protecting online content onto rights holders. Rather than requiring AI companies to identify protected works and secure authorization, creators could be expected to identify where their material is being used and take steps to prevent its inclusion in training datasets.

The effectiveness of technical opt-out mechanisms is therefore a significant concern for international publishers and other rights holders whose material is made available online. For businesses operating across multiple jurisdictions, differing approaches to AI training permissions could also create additional compliance challenges, particularly where technical signals are not consistently recognized or respected by AI developers.

The Australian government continues to consult with creators, media organizations and technology companies on possible copyright reforms. The Copyright Agency confirmed on November 11 that the government was still considering whether to amend the Copyright Act, with the precise nature of any changes yet to be determined.

As discussions continue, Sims’s intervention highlights a fundamental question for copyright policy: should the responsibility for securing permission rest with AI developers, or should creators have to take affirmative steps to prevent their work from being used?

Elizabeth Jordan

Written by Elizabeth Jordan

Senior Industry Engagement Manager, CTC Legal Media

haynes boone

You may also like…

Contact us to write for out Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Our weekly newsletter is exclusively based on trademarks, instead of a generic IP newsletter! We also will be including a selection of the top articles from The Trademark Lawyermagazine. Please enter your details below to be included in our mailing list.

You have Successfully Subscribed!